![]() He made these remarks while speaking on a conference panel that specifically focused on envisioning hypothetical scenarios that entailed nuclear weapons use.Īs scholars often do in such gatherings, Narang went for a counterintuitive scenario rather than the run-of-the-mill one that would have envisioned a Pakistani first use, probably of its tactical nuclear weapon against invading Indian conventional forces. Vipin Narang is a well-respected Indian-American scholar who neither speaks for the Indian establishment, nor claims to have any clout over it. The NFU saga is also a storm in a teacup, no more. Know more: Tactical N-weapons are here to stay, says adviser Moreover, the Nasr missile defies decades of experience during the Cold War that confirms the exorbitant risks attached to fielding battlefield nuclear weapons.įor now, Nasr has offered the latest reason for the world to question the dangers posed by Pakistan’s nuclear programme. Most objective analysts agree that Cold Start is simply not executable, and even if it were, Pakistan’s conventional forces could easily tackle it. Pakistan reacted, in fact overreacted, by developing a fresh tactical nuclear weapon capability. ![]() The state has never believed in the sanctity of the Indian NFU. I argued that Pakistan hadn’t and wouldn’t because Cold Start did not alter the military’s Order of Battle, or its ability to neutralise India’s conventional aggression, given that its short lines of communication and forward bases already secured it against such an Indian adventure. The question posed to me was why Pakistan had not reacted to the doctrine in any visible way. In 2007, three years after Cold Start was floated, I, along with several other scholars, analysed this Indian doctrine threadbare. Cold Start offered India an option to wage limited war that would punish Pakistan selectively, without bringing Pakistani nuclear use in response into play.Įxamine: Has India’s army revived its ‘Cold Start’ doctrine? In that crisis, India not only discovered that its nuclear weapons have no bearing on the ability of terrorists to strike inside India, but also that its ability to leverage its superior conventional might was neutralised by Pakistan’s nuclear deterrent. I am alarmed because I found some of these conversations to be strikingly similar to what I heard a decade ago when the Indian army floated its Cold Start doctrine - a Pakistan-specific limited war strategy conceived by the Indian army after the 2001-02 crisis with Pakistan. In the past few weeks, I have heard regular references to Narang’s comments in Pakistani policy circles, and even discussions suggesting that Pakistan must consider its implications seriously. ![]() I would have usually dismissed the response as business as usual. See: India may use nuclear option first to pre-empt attack: expert Since, the Pakistani state and several experts have pointed to the Indian hypocrisy of claiming an NFU that they no longer plan to honour. Last month, Indian-American scholar Vipin Narang stirred a storm by casting doubt on the sanctity of India’s No-First-Use (NFU) pledge on nuclear weapons and positing the possibility of Indian pre-emptive strikes against Pakistan. Once you have grasped the facts of a subject, your creativity and abstract approach lifts your thinking beyond the rudimentary to the philosophical.The writer is a foreign policy expert based in Washington, DC You have a natural gift for analysis and research. ![]() You search beneath the surface of things. You value the gifts of your mind, which you use to great advantage to penetrate the mysteries of life. You are not the type to embark on any trip without a map.” Inner analysis of storm in a teacup by heart number 7 You enjoy management systems, and can carry out your well laid plans. You possess a highly developed sense of structure. ![]() Your approach to life and to problems is methodical and systematic. “You are the bedrock of society, the foundation of any enterprise. Talent analysis of storm in a teacup by expression number 4 Storm in a teacup name Numerology Numerology (Expression Number) ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Details
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |